Comparison

The alias-specialized Proton Pass alternative

Proton Pass bundles aliases (via SimpleLogin) with a password manager. EmailAlias goes deep on the alias problem — sender-risk scoring, exposure analytics, REST API, MCP server — without locking you into a Proton account.

Why people pick EmailAlias over Proton Pass aliases

  • Sender-risk intelligence, built in

    Pass's privacy story stops at hiding your address. EmailAlias also scores every inbound sender on phishing signals — risky TLDs, typosquatting, suspicious keywords — and surfaces a per-alias risk dashboard plus real-time alerts when a high-risk sender lands on one.

  • REST API + MCP server

    Pass is UI-driven; there's no documented alias API. EmailAlias has a REST API and an open-source MCP server so Claude Desktop, Cursor, Zed, and ChatGPT Custom GPTs can manage aliases conversationally — useful for bulk creation, internal tooling, or just chatting with your inbox.

  • Specialized, not bundled

    Pass aims to be a password manager and an alias service in one. EmailAlias does one thing: aliases. If you already have a password manager (1Password, Bitwarden, KeePass), bundling doesn't help — and two specialized tools usually beat one general one.

  • Independent — no Proton account needed

    Pass aliases on Proton-owned domains stop working if you cancel Proton. EmailAlias doesn't require a separate ecosystem login. Use your own custom domain on Premium and the aliases stay portable to any provider, including back to Proton if you ever change your mind.

Feature comparison

Feature
EmailAlias
Proton Pass
Alias forwarding to your real inbox
Reply from alias
Custom domains with SPF / DKIM / DMARC
Free tier with usable alias count
Suspicious-sender risk scoring
Per-alias exposure / forwarding dashboard
REST API + MCP server for AI integrations
Inline alias generator on every signup form
Independent (no separate ecosystem account)
Bundled with a password manager
End-to-end encrypted vault (passwords + notes)
7-day free trial on paid tier

Pricing side-by-side

Both have free tiers. Pass Plus bundles a password manager into the price; EmailAlias Premium stays alias-focused and prices accordingly.

Free plan

Detail
EmailAlias
Proton Pass
Price
$0
$0
Aliases included
10
10 (Hide My Email)
Custom domains
Reply from alias
Included
Exposure / sender-risk alerts
Weekly digest (high-risk only)

Paid plan

Detail
EmailAlias
Proton Pass
Monthly price
$4 / mo
$4.99 / mo (Pass Plus)
Aliases included
Unlimited (fair-use cap)
Unlimited
Custom domains
Up to 5
Yes (Pass Plus)
Reply from alias
Included
Included
Sender-risk alerts
Real-time (any score ≥ 15)
MCP server / AI integrations
Included
Free trial / refund
7-day trial
30-day money-back guarantee

Pass Plus pricing reflects Proton's standard monthly tier. Annual and bundle pricing may differ — verify on proton.me before subscribing.

How to switch from Proton Pass aliases in 5 steps

Most users finish in 15–20 minutes. You don't have to cancel Proton — Pass keeps working as a password manager if you want it to.

  1. 1

    Inventory your Proton Pass aliases

    Open Proton Pass → Hide My Email and list every alias plus the service you gave it to. Most users have 10–50 aliases; a CSV export isn't needed — a copy-paste is enough.

  2. 2

    Create your EmailAlias account

    Sign up at emailalias.io with the same destination inbox. Premium starts with a 7-day free trial — activate it if you need multiple custom domains.

  3. 3

    Re-create the aliases on EmailAlias

    For each Proton Pass alias, mint a fresh @emailalias.io alias (or one on your custom domain) and label it with the service. If you used Pass Plus's custom-domain feature, you can move the domain to EmailAlias and keep the exact same alias addresses.

  4. 4

    Update each service to the new alias

    Log into each service and change the email on file. The browser extension generates a fresh alias inline on any signup form, so future accounts don't even need a dashboard visit.

  5. 5

    Disable the Proton Pass aliases

    Once your EmailAlias dashboard shows traffic on every new alias (give it 2–4 weeks to catch the long tail), disable the Proton Pass aliases. You don't need to cancel Pass Plus — keep using it as a password manager if you want, but your aliases now live in a dedicated platform.

Tip: overlap both services for 2–4 weeks. Anything you forgot to update still gets delivered through Pass, and you can disable old aliases once your EmailAlias dashboard shows them sitting idle.

Frequently asked questions

The questions we get most often from people moving over from Proton Pass.

Can I move my aliases between providers?

Aliases on a shared provider domain (e.g. @emailalias.io) aren't portable — they live on our domain and stay with us. Aliases on a custom domain (yourdomain.com) are fully portable: you keep the domain, point its MX records at a new provider, re-create the same local-parts on their side, and the addresses keep working — provided the new provider supports custom local-parts (most do; some only issue random codes). Custom domains are a Premium feature on EmailAlias, but for anyone who plans to use aliases long-term, it's vendor-independence insurance worth having.

What does Premium include?

Unlimited aliases, up to 5 custom domains, unlimited verified forwarding inboxes (so each alias can route to the right mailbox), send & reply from any alias, real-time leak detection with exposure analytics, and priority processing — all for $4/month or $35/year (save 27%).

What happens if a service I signed up for gets breached?

Because each service has its own unique alias, you'll know exactly which service leaked your data — when spam or phishing hits that alias, the source is obvious. Our exposure intelligence engine also flags suspicious senders in real time. Disable the affected alias and your real email stays safe.

Isn't Proton Pass the same thing as SimpleLogin?

Proton acquired SimpleLogin in 2022 and integrated its alias backend into Proton Pass. The SimpleLogin website and tier still exist, but most new users land in Pass. If you're comparing Pass aliases, you're effectively comparing SimpleLogin's engine with Proton's password-manager front-end on top. The alias mechanics are the same; the difference vs EmailAlias is sender-risk scoring, exposure analytics, and our REST API + MCP server.

I want a password manager too — should I just use Pass?

If you don't already have a password manager and you specifically want one tied to your aliasing service, Pass is a reasonable choice. EmailAlias is alias-specialized — we don't try to be a password manager. Many users pair EmailAlias with 1Password, Bitwarden, or KeePass (which they were already using) instead of switching to a bundled product. It depends on whether you want one tool that does both okay or two tools that each do their job well.

Does Proton Pass score senders for risk?

No. Pass's privacy story is the encrypted vault + the alias — sender-risk intelligence isn't part of the product. EmailAlias runs continuous risk scoring on every inbound message (risky TLDs, typosquatting, phishing keywords) and surfaces a per-alias risk dashboard plus real-time alerts when a high-risk sender hits an alias. That's the main thing this page exists to highlight.

Will my aliases still work if I leave the Proton ecosystem?

Aliases on @proton.me / @passmail.com / shared Pass domains stop working when you cancel Proton — those addresses are tied to the account. Custom-domain aliases are portable if you used Pass Plus's custom-domain feature: repoint MX records to a new provider, re-create the local-parts, and the addresses keep working. EmailAlias supports the same custom-domain portability without requiring a separate ecosystem subscription.

Does Proton Pass have an API or MCP server?

Not for aliases at the time of writing. Proton publishes APIs for some Proton services, but Pass alias management is primarily UI-driven. EmailAlias ships a REST API and an open-source MCP server so AI assistants (Claude Desktop, Cursor, Zed, ChatGPT Custom GPTs) can create, list, and audit aliases conversationally — useful if you want to script bulk alias creation, integrate with internal tooling, or chat with your inbox.

More questions? See the full FAQ.

Specialize on the alias problem

Sender-risk alerts, per-alias exposure dashboards, REST API + MCP server — features Pass doesn't ship. Start your 7-day free trial.