The short version

  • Both are solid, trustworthy alias services. Firefox Relay comes from Mozilla and is the simplest to start with; SimpleLogin comes from Proton, is open source, and gives you more control.
  • On the free plans, SimpleLogin gives you more. It offers 10 aliases and lets you reply from them; Firefox Relay’s free plan offers 5 masks and saves replying for Premium.
  • Pick by what you need. Firefox Relay suits Firefox users who want simple masks, tracker removal or phone masking in a supported country. SimpleLogin suits people who want custom domains, PGP, multiple mailboxes or the option to self-host.

Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin is one of the most common comparisons people make when they first decide to stop handing out their real email address. Both services do the same core job: they give you private forwarding addresses, called masks or aliases, that pass mail on to your real inbox while keeping it hidden. Both are run by respected privacy-focused organisations. And both have a genuinely useful free plan.

The differences are in the details, and they matter more than the headline features suggest: how many addresses you get for free, whether you can reply, what happens with custom domains and attachments, and who stands behind the service. This guide compares Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin point by point, using each service’s own published plans and help pages, and ends with a clear answer for each type of user.

What Firefox Relay and SimpleLogin Have in Common

Before looking at differences, it’s worth being clear about how much these two services share, because for many people either one would do the job well.

  • The same basic idea. You create a separate address for each site or app. Mail sent to that address is forwarded to your real inbox, and the sender never learns your real address.
  • Per-address control. If one address starts receiving spam or shows up in a data breach, you switch that one off without touching the rest.
  • Browser extensions. Both offer extensions so you can create a new address right inside a sign-up form.
  • A free plan. Both let you start without paying, and both offer a paid plan with unlimited addresses.
  • Trusted owners. Firefox Relay is made by Mozilla, the organisation behind Firefox. SimpleLogin is a product of Proton, the Swiss company behind Proton Mail.

If you are new to the idea, our explainer on email masks covers the basics. The rest of this Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin comparison focuses on where the two genuinely differ.

Firefox Relay: Mozilla’s Email Masks

Firefox Relay calls its addresses “email masks”. Its pitch is simplicity: sign in with a Mozilla account, install the extension, and create a mask whenever a site asks for your email. Masks forward to your real address, and you manage them from a dashboard where you can label them, turn forwarding off, or block particular kinds of mail.

A few features stand out. Relay can remove common email trackers from forwarded mail, which helps stop senders seeing when and where you open a message; even the free plan includes this. Premium subscribers can block promotional emails on a mask while still receiving receipts and other important mail. Premium also gives you a unique Relay subdomain, so you can make up new masks on the spot without opening the dashboard.

Relay also goes beyond email. Its higher tier adds a phone mask, a separate number that forwards calls and texts to your real phone, and another tier bundles Mozilla VPN. That makes it attractive if you want one Mozilla account to cover several kinds of privacy.

There are two practical limits to know. According to Relay’s FAQ, Relay Premium is currently sold only in a listed set of countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, most of the EU, Switzerland, New Zealand, Singapore and Malaysia; elsewhere you can use the free plan and join a waitlist. And Relay itself advises against using masks where you need your identity verified or must receive important attachments.

SimpleLogin: Proton’s Open-Source Aliases

SimpleLogin calls its addresses “aliases” and leans towards power and flexibility. It started as an independent open-source project and is now a product of Proton AG, registered in Switzerland. All of its code is public on GitHub, so anyone can audit it, and technically minded users can run their own SimpleLogin server.

Its feature list is longer than Relay’s. You can reply from any alias, even on the free plan. Premium adds custom domains, so you can create addresses on a domain you own; catch-all, so any address at your domain works without being created first; multiple mailboxes, so different aliases can forward to different real inboxes; and PGP encryption, so forwarded mail is encrypted with your own key before it reaches your inbox. SimpleLogin also has apps for iOS and Android alongside extensions for Chrome, Firefox and Safari.

Since joining Proton, SimpleLogin Premium also includes Proton Pass premium features, such as the password manager’s vault sharing and built-in authenticator. If you already use Proton Mail, SimpleLogin fits in naturally, though it works with any inbox.

Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin: Free Plans Compared

For many people the free plan decides the Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin question on its own, so it deserves a careful look.

Firefox Relay’s free plan gives you 5 email masks, the browser extension, and tracker removal. You can’t reply from a mask on the free plan, and you don’t get a personal subdomain.

SimpleLogin’s free plan, according to its pricing page, gives you 10 aliases, unlimited bandwidth, replying from your aliases, one mailbox, browser extensions and mobile apps, and two-factor authentication for your account.

That makes SimpleLogin’s free plan the more generous of the two: twice the addresses, plus replying. Five masks fills up quickly once you start using a separate one for each shop, newsletter and app. Relay’s advantage on the free plan is tracker removal, which SimpleLogin doesn’t advertise as a free feature.

Both services offer unlimited addresses on their paid plans, so the real comparison is in what else you get.

Firefox Relay Premium adds unlimited masks, blocking of promotional emails, your own Relay subdomain for creating masks on the fly, and replying from your masks. A higher tier adds a phone mask, and another bundles Mozilla VPN. Prices are shown by country and the plan is only sold in the supported countries, so check the Relay Premium page for the current price where you live.

SimpleLogin Premium costs $36 per year or $4 billed monthly. It adds unlimited aliases, unlimited custom domains, catch-all, sending a brand-new email from an alias, 5 subdomains, 50 “directories” for creating aliases on the fly, unlimited mailboxes, PGP encryption, and Proton Pass premium features.

Both handle cancellation gracefully. If you stop paying for SimpleLogin, the aliases you created keep working for sending and receiving; you just can’t create new ones beyond the free limit. Relay works similarly: existing masks keep forwarding, but you lose replies and can’t create more than 5 masks in total.

In short, Relay Premium is about convenience and breadth across email, phone and VPN. SimpleLogin Premium is about depth: domains, mailboxes, encryption and fine-grained control. If you want to see what a year of each kind of service costs alongside a third option, our SimpleLogin vs addy.io vs EmailAlias comparison breaks that down.

Replying and Sending

Replying is where Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin differ most in day-to-day use. Being able to reply from an alias matters whenever you need to talk to a seller, a support desk or a landlord without revealing your real address.

With SimpleLogin, you just press Reply in your normal mail app. The reply goes through SimpleLogin, which sends it from the alias, so your real address stays hidden. This works on the free plan, with no limit on the number of replies. On Premium you can also start a brand-new conversation from an alias using a “reverse alias”.

With Firefox Relay, replying needs Premium, and you can reply to a forwarded email within 3 months of receiving it. Relay’s FAQ includes an important warning: if you add a CC or BCC when replying, your real address is exposed to everyone on the email. That’s worth remembering whichever service you use.

firefox relay vs simplelogin: a reply travelling back through a private alias so the real inbox stays hidden
When you reply through an alias, the service sends the message on your behalf, so the recipient only ever sees the alias.

Our guide to replying from an email alias explains how this works behind the scenes and the mistakes that can give your real address away.

Custom Domains, Attachments and Mailboxes

Three practical features tend to matter more the longer you use an alias service.

Custom domains. SimpleLogin Premium lets you bring your own domain and create addresses like shop@yourname.com, with catch-all so you can invent addresses on the spot. This is the most future-proof setup, because addresses on your own domain can move with you if you ever change provider. Firefox Relay offers a personal subdomain of its own domain on Premium, but not your own domain. Our guide to custom domain email aliases explains why this matters.

Attachments. Relay’s FAQ notes that forwarded emails with attachments larger than 10 MB won’t arrive. SimpleLogin’s FAQ gives a maximum email size of 25 MB. If you regularly receive large files, SimpleLogin has more headroom, though for very large files a link is better with either service.

Mailboxes. SimpleLogin Premium lets you add several real inboxes and choose which one each alias forwards to, which is handy for keeping work and personal mail apart. Relay forwards masks to your own email address and doesn’t advertise routing different masks to different inboxes.

Privacy, Ownership and Open Source

Since the whole point of an alias service is privacy, it’s fair to ask who handles your mail and how openly.

SimpleLogin is fully open source, so its code can be inspected by anyone, and it can be self-hosted if you’d rather not trust a provider at all. It is owned by Proton AG in Switzerland, and its FAQ says it uses servers from Proton and from UpCloud in Finland. Optional PGP encryption means forwarded mail can be encrypted to your key before it reaches your inbox.

Firefox Relay is run by Mozilla, which has a long track record on browser privacy, and its code is also public on GitHub. Its FAQ explains that Relay records the websites where you use each mask and labels the mask with that site, so you can tell your masks apart. That’s convenient, but worth knowing if you’d prefer the service to hold as little as possible. Relay also sets out acceptable-use measures, such as limiting how many masks can be created per day, to prevent abuse.

Neither service is a privacy risk for ordinary use, and both are far better than handing your real address to every site. Both publish their code, but if self-hosting or encrypting forwarded mail with your own key is important to you, SimpleLogin has the edge in this Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin matchup. If you mostly want a simple tool from a familiar name, Relay is a comfortable choice.

Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin Compared

Here is the Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin comparison in one table, based on each service’s published plans and help pages.

Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin on free and paid features (checked on relay.firefox.com and simplelogin.io, November 2026)
FeatureFirefox RelaySimpleLogin
Made byMozillaProton AG (Switzerland)
Free addresses5 masks10 aliases
Reply on free planNoYes
Paid priceVaries by country; sold in listed countries only$36/year or $4 billed monthly
Unlimited addresses (paid)YesYes
Reply on paid planYes, within 3 months of receivingYes, plus start new emails
Own custom domainNo (personal Relay subdomain)Yes, unlimited, with catch-all
Tracker removalYes, including freeNot advertised
Multiple real inboxesNot advertisedYes, on Premium
PGP encryptionNoYes, on Premium
Max attachment / email sizeAttachments over 10 MB not forwarded25 MB per email
Phone maskingYes, higher tierNo
Open source / self-hostCode on GitHub; self-hosting not advertisedOpen source and self-hostable
Mobile appsDashboard on any deviceiOS and Android apps

Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin: Which Should You Choose?

Here is how to settle Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin for your own situation:

  • You want the simplest possible start and use Firefox. Choose Firefox Relay. The free plan is enough to try aliases on a handful of sites, and tracker removal is a nice bonus.
  • You want to stay on a free plan for a while. Choose SimpleLogin. Ten aliases and free replies go a lot further than five masks.
  • You need to reply to people without revealing your address. SimpleLogin, because replying works on the free plan and has no 3-month window.
  • You want a masked phone number too. Firefox Relay, if you live in a country where its phone tier is sold.
  • You own a domain or want addresses that can move with you. SimpleLogin, for custom domains and catch-all.
  • You already use Proton Mail. SimpleLogin fits naturally and adds Proton Pass premium features on its paid plan.
  • You want to self-host or audit the code. SimpleLogin.
  • Relay Premium isn’t sold in your country. SimpleLogin, or another alias service, since you’d otherwise be stuck on 5 free masks.

Your choice isn’t permanent, either. If you start on one and later move to the other, you don’t have to change every account at once: leave the old addresses forwarding, create new ones on the new service, and update each account’s email address the next time you log in. Addresses that receive nothing for a few months can simply be switched off. Doing it gradually like this avoids missing any important email during the move.

Overall, SimpleLogin is the stronger choice for most people who plan to use aliases seriously, while Firefox Relay is an excellent, low-effort starting point. If you’d like to compare more options than these two, our lists of Firefox Relay alternatives and SimpleLogin alternatives cover six of each.

A Third Option Worth Knowing

To be upfront: EmailAlias, which publishes this guide, is also an alias service. If neither Firefox Relay nor SimpleLogin is quite right for you, it’s worth a look, particularly for one feature the other two don’t focus on.

The free plan includes 10 permanent aliases on our email91.com domain, with no credit card. Premium at $4 per month adds replying from your aliases, custom domains, and leak detection that warns you when one of your aliases turns up in a data breach or starts receiving mail from risky senders, so you know which company exposed you. Developers can create aliases through the API at https://emailalias.io/api. You can see how we compare directly on our Firefox Relay and SimpleLogin comparison pages, or browse the wider field in our guide to the best email alias services.

Final Thoughts

There is no wrong answer in Firefox Relay vs SimpleLogin; both will protect your real address far better than giving it out everywhere. Firefox Relay is the friendlier on-ramp, with a familiar name, tracker removal and the option of phone masking where it’s sold. SimpleLogin is the more capable tool, with a more generous free plan, replies from day one, custom domains, PGP and open-source code you can run yourself. Start with the one that matches how you’ll actually use it, and remember that the bigger win is simply using a separate address for every site. If you want to cut tracking in the mail you do receive, our guide on how to block email trackers is a good next step whichever service you choose.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Firefox Relay or SimpleLogin better?

It depends on how you’ll use it. SimpleLogin is better for most heavy users: its free plan has 10 aliases and replies, and Premium adds custom domains, catch-all, multiple mailboxes and PGP. Firefox Relay is better if you want the simplest start, tracker removal on the free plan, or a masked phone number in a country where that’s sold.

How many free aliases do Firefox Relay and SimpleLogin give you?

Firefox Relay’s free plan includes 5 email masks. SimpleLogin’s free plan includes 10 aliases. Both offer unlimited addresses on their paid plans.

Can I reply from Firefox Relay for free?

No. Replying from a Firefox Relay mask requires Relay Premium, and you can reply to a forwarded email within 3 months of receiving it. SimpleLogin lets you reply from any alias on its free plan. With either service, don’t add CC or BCC when replying, or your real address is exposed.

How much do Firefox Relay Premium and SimpleLogin Premium cost?

SimpleLogin Premium costs $36 per year or $4 billed monthly. Firefox Relay Premium’s price is shown by country, and the plan is only sold in a listed set of countries including the US, UK, Canada, most of the EU, Switzerland, New Zealand, Singapore and Malaysia. Check relay.firefox.com for the price where you live.

Does Firefox Relay or SimpleLogin support custom domains?

SimpleLogin Premium supports unlimited custom domains with catch-all, so you can create addresses on a domain you own. Firefox Relay Premium gives you a personal subdomain on Relay’s own domain, but not your own custom domain.

Is SimpleLogin owned by Proton?

Yes. SimpleLogin is a product of Proton AG, the Swiss company behind Proton Mail. It remains open source, can be self-hosted, and its Premium plan now includes Proton Pass premium features.

Which handles attachments better, Firefox Relay or SimpleLogin?

SimpleLogin allows emails up to 25 MB. Firefox Relay doesn’t forward emails with attachments larger than 10 MB. For very large files, sending a download link is more reliable with either service.

Is there an alternative to both Firefox Relay and SimpleLogin?

Yes. Other alias services include addy.io, DuckDuckGo Email Protection, Apple Hide My Email and EmailAlias. EmailAlias offers 10 free permanent aliases, and Premium at $4 per month adds replies, custom domains and leak detection that alerts you when an alias appears in a data breach.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.